"Whispering" Bill Anderson was recorded in March 1974 at Bradley's Barn, a studio located in Mount Juliet, Tennessee owned by the album's producer Owen Bradley, Anderson's longtime musical collaborator.

The track, "Country Song", was written by Jack Clement, a Nashville music producer.

The opening track, "Can I Come Home to You", was co-written by Jan Crutchfield and producer Buddy Killen.

"Again, a great collection of material sung in the Anderson style which puts him consistently at the top.

It's a great variety of songs, including a little recitation, some fine ballads, an up-tempo tune or two, and real class," staff writers commented.