The episode was written by Barbie Kligman and Gabrielle Stanton and directed by Rick Bota.
The episode starts with Stefan (Paul Wesley) waking up at the living room and hearing noises in the house.
He thinks that is Damon (Ian Somerhalder) but it is really his old friend Lexi (Arielle Kebbel) who came to celebrate his birthday.
At the police station, Sheriff Forbes (Marguerite MacIntyre) interrogates everyone about Vicki's (Kayla Ewell) disappearance.
Stefan and Elena match their stories that Stefan was just trying to help her with her drug issues, Jeremy (Steven R. McQueen) only remembers the things Damon compelled him to remember and Matt (Zach Roerig) does not know anything other than what Jeremy told him.
Sheriff Forbes works late when Damon arrives at her office to bring her a package (supposedly from uncle Zach) that contains vervain.
Bonnie tries to cheer her up by showing her a trick her grandmother taught her and she tells her that she is truly a witch.
At the Salvatore house, Stefan and Lexi talk about Elena when Damon shows up to invite them to Caroline's party later.
Lexi immediately runs back to the bedroom and ask Stefan what is wrong with him and why is he after a girl who looks like Katherine's twin sister.
When he gets out he sees a young couple making out, he attacks them, kills the boy and compels the girl.
Elena changes her mind and arrives at the party seeing Lexi and Stefan having fun while playing pool.
She trips and falls and when she rises her eyes she sees her ancestor Emily (Bianca Lawson) warning her that "It's coming".
Bonnie wakes up terrified but she is no longer in her bed but in the cemetery, at the Salvatore crypt.
[5] Lucia from Heroine TV also gave a good review to the episode saying: "...this was another thoroughly entertaining episode, with great moments for all the characters involved — even my often-neglected favorites, Matt and Bonnie (hurrah for screen time!).