The club did not play in a league, but played a large number of friendlies and matches in local cup competitions as well as taking part in the qualifying rounds of the FA Cup and FA Amateur Cup.

New Brompton's first ever match was at home to the reserves of Woolwich Arsenal on 2 September 1893, a match which the away team won 5–1.

[1] New Brompton entered at the first qualifying round stage, but lost 6–3 away to Ilford.

[1] New Brompton beat Maidstone United and Royal Scots Fusiliers before losing 2–1 to Royal Ordnance.

[1] New Brompton won this minor local competition, beating Sheppey United 3–1 in the final on 14 April.