The format that was originally announced in October 1896 was that after fourteen weeks of home-and-away matches, a finals series would be played as a simple four-team knock-out tournament amongst the top four clubs, and the gate takings from the semi-finals would be donated to charity.
However, when inclement weather on that weekend forced the postponement of the charity round, the league used this opportunity to abandon this finals system and develop a new one.
[7] This decision was later reversed after Geelong, who had won the minor premiership, lodged an official complaint with the league stating that this arrangement would be unfair to the club and its supporters.
The league agreed with this assessment, and when the finals system was determined on August 17, Geelong was scheduled to host its match in the first week.
Geelong finished the stronger team to defeat Melbourne, with a goal by Eddy James near the end winning the game for them.
In the low-scoring encounter, Melbourne hit the post three times, and a goal by Essendon player Norman Waugh was disallowed after the bell.
Geelong's brilliant first-quarter burst meant Collingwood's chances of making it back into the match were near impossible.