The only two individuals who have been recognized as "official" selectors by the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) for the 1900 season are Walter Camp and Caspar Whitney, who had originated the College Football All-America Team eleven years earlier in 1889.
[1] The Yale Bulldogs (Camp's alma mater) had seven players who were designated as consensus All-Americans.
Two western players were selected by Camp for his third team: Page, a fullback for Minnesota; and Clyde Williams, a quarterback for Iowa.
The list below includes the All-America selections made by Charles Sargent for Leslie's Weekly and George W. Orton for The Philadelphia Inquirer.
They were James Bloomer, Gordon Brown, Truxton Hare, and end John Hallowell of Harvard.