[7] The Jersey AC/British American match ended ten minutes early on account of darkness and was ordered replayed.

The Thistles also withdrew from the competition when the AFA decided to order a replay of their match with the Rovers.

The draw for the third round of the American Cup took place at the Continental Hotel in Newark, NJ on December 3, 1908.

[18] The True Blue/H & B match was protested on account of ineligible players and ordered replayed.

Home teams listed on top of bracket