It took three matches for them to overcome their final opponents Tacony of Philadelphia aka the 'Tacks'.

Another notable encounter between New Jersey teams was a four game duel between Newark Caledonians and the Paterson Rangers in the second round.

The draw was held September 14, 1912 at the Continental hotel in Newark, NJ.

The Olympic–True Blue match was replayed because they both wore very similar style and color of uniforms.

As the home team, the True Blue squad was obligated to don an alternate kit in this situation.