The team finished fourth in the National League with a record of 75–78, 29 games behind the New York Giants.

Cincinnati had a tough season offensively, as the club ranked last in batting average (.256), on base percentage (.323), hits (1310), doubles (183) and home runs (21).

First baseman Dick Hoblitzell hit .294 and had 85 RBI, however, his home run total dropped from eleven in 1911 to only two in 1912.

Outfielder Armando Marsans led the Reds with a .317 batting average, while hitting one home run and 38 RBI in 110 games.

Infielders Coaches Note: Pos = Position; G = Games played; AB = At bats; H = Hits; Avg.