St. Mary's (Ohio) football, 1910–1919

In its first season under head coach Orville Smith, the team compiled a 5–1 record.

In its first season under head coach Roland Bevan, the team compiled a 3–3–1 record.

In its second and final season under head coach Roland Bevan, the team compiled a 4–2 record.

In its third and final season under head coach Alfred McCray, the team compiled a 4–3 record.

In its third and final season under head coach Louis Clark, the team compiled a 1–1 record.