Columbia started its second season under Tom Howard with a 3-game series against Dartmouth in Lake Placid, New York.

After a win over the Lord Jeffs, Columbia was hoping for a repeat performance against Princeton but instead the Tigers throttled the Lions by a 0–14 score.

[2] Coach Howard didn't allow the team to surrender after the embarrassing loss and ran the Lions through hard practices leading up to their next game against Pennsylvania.

The team had played multiple ineligible players under false names after the Princeton game, a violation of sportsmanship and committee regulations in the eyes of Columbia University administration.

However, when a distinct lack of ice rinks became apparent the following November, Columbia announced that they were cancelling the season.