In their first season under head coach Jesse Hawley, the Indians compiled an 8–1 record, shut out five of nine opponents, and outscored all opponents by a total of 202 to 54.

[1] In November 1923, Dartmouth began a 22-game unbeaten streak that continued until October 1926.

[2] Cyril J. Aschenbach was the team captain.

H. Lester Haws was the team's leading scorer with 60 points scored on 10 touchdowns.

This college football 1923 season article is a stub.