Labour's neutral position merely ended up displeasing both sides, however, and Nash was widely accused of indecision and lack of courage.

In May 1953, Rex Mason informed Nash that several members were complaining to him about the party's leadership to him and that he thought that the majority wanted a new leader to take over.

While his leadership was questioned by caucus colleagues, Nash had overwhelming support from the Trade Unions, who backed the party financially.

Likewise, party branches from all over the country passed resolutions confirming their support for Nash, sending a message to prospective challengers.

[5] Under pressure from the grass roots members and trade unions, the majority of Labour's caucus voted for Nash.