The consensus 1957 College Basketball All-American team, as determined by aggregating the results of six major All-American teams.

[1] To earn 'consensus' status, a player must win honors from a majority of the following teams: the Associated Press, the USBWA, The United Press International, the National Association of Basketball Coaches, the Newspaper Enterprise Association (NEA), and the International News Service.

AP Honorable Mention:[6]