The 1958 Northeastern State Redmen football team represented Northeastern State University as a member of the Oklahoma Collegiate Conference (OCC) during the 1958 NAIA football season.
Guard Claude Billingsley won NAIA All-America honors.
Seven Northeastern State players received first-team honors on the 1958 All-Oklahoma Collegiate Conference teams selected by the seven conference coaches: Billingsley; Smith (unanimous choice); quarterback Frankie Phelps (unanimous choice); end Charles Moore; tackle Joe Kiger; center Lynn Burris; and fullback Deloyd Reed.
Three others received second-team honors: end Fred Hood; tackle James Barrett; and guard Roger Wickersham.
[1] The team played its home games at Gable Field in Tahlequah, Oklahoma.