General elections were held in the Pitcairn Islands on 15 December 2004.
For the mayoralty, Jay Warren defeated Mike Warren and the incumbent Brenda Christian, who had held the office since 8 November in an interim capacity following Governor Richard Fell's dismissal of her brother, Steve Christian, on 29 October following his five rape convictions.
The four ordinary councillors to be elected were Meralda Warren, Olive Christian, Carol Warren and Lea Brown.
Speaking from his British High Commission office in Wellington, New Zealand, Deputy Governor Matthew Forbes told Radio New Zealand that he welcomed Jay Warren's election as mayor.
"We appointed Jay as chairman of the (island's) internal committee in the period after the trials and before this election," Forbes said.