The 2011–12 season was Stenhousemuir's third consecutive season in the Scottish Second Division, having been promoted from the Scottish Third Division at the end of the 2008–09 season.

[1] Stenhousemuir also competed in the Challenge Cup, League Cup and the Scottish Cup.

Stenhousemuir finished fifth in the Second Division.

[2] They reached the first round of the Challenge Cup,[3] the second round of the League Cup[4] and the fourth round of the Scottish Cup.

[5] Win Draw Loss Postponed Includes all competitive matches.