It is City's second consecutive year in the third tier of American soccer, playing in the USL Professional Division for their second season.

[1] They ended the season with winning the league title for the second consecutive year, but they lost in the Playoffs to the Wilmington Hammerheads in the Semi-final 3–4.

Rawlins was able to bring international matches to the city in 2011 when Orlando played English Premier League sides Bolton Wanderers and Newcastle United.

Source: Match reports As part of the new format for the U.S. Open Cup in 2012, Orlando City entered with the other U.S.-based teams from USL Pro and the NASL in the second round.

* = Denotes players who were retained after the move of the Austin Aztex FC organization to form Orlando City S.C.