Note: Flags indicate national team as defined under FIFA eligibility rules.

Last updated: November 4, 2013 Source: Columbus Crew Pld = Matches played; Pts = Points; W = Matches won; T = Matches tied; L = Matches lost; GF = Goals for; GA = Goals against; GD = Goal difference Avila  29' Bowen  76' Iraheta  79' Williams 89' Arrieta 46' 88' Gaven  51' Wahl  78' Higuaín  86' Sánchez  91' Daniel  70' Higuaín  59' Thompson  13' Larentowicz 83' Agustín Viana  21' Josh Williams 26' Danny O'Rourke  45' Federico Higuaín 45+1' (pen.)

Daniel Woolard  48' Juninho  74' Dillon Powers 70' Wahl  60' Gláuber  78' Juninho Pernambucano  66' Sánchez  41' Higuaín 74' (pen.)

Camargo  55' Williams 29' Casey 31' Oduro 22' O'Rourke  82' Arrieta  45' Lindpere  48' Duka 52' Magee 54' Segares  60' Bieler 50' Oduro 53' Wahl  68' Williams 66' Eckersley  72' Osorio 87'  88' García  27' Bruin 32' Higuaín 61' (pen.)

77' Trapp  45' The Columbus Crew failed to qualify for the playoffs in this season.