Siena, picked sixth, controlled their own destiny, beat Monmouth and clinched their first outright MAAC regular season championship in almost a decade.

Upstart Saint Peter's, picked ninth, would finish one game behind Siena, so close to their first conference championship since 1987.

Iona, who was the preseason favorite in the MAAC, was without their coach Tim Cluess, who missed the entire 2019–20 season with an undisclosed illness, and finished in sixth place.

Siena, who was the #1 seed, and who had won their quarterfinal game, would have been the MAAC's automatic bid to the NCAA tournament should it have been held.

On March 12, the tournament, as well as all other NCAA championships for the remainder of the academic season, were cancelled due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

[9] Notes: () first place votes † denotes unanimous selection This table summarizes the final head-to-head results between teams in conference play during the regular season.