Georgetown successfully defended their Big East Tournament title, and also won the regular season.

This was Georgetown's first national championship in men's soccer, and their first College Cup appearance since 2012.

Ahead of the 2019 season, Creighton head coach Elmar Bolowich was hired by professional soccer club, Jacksonville Armada FC.

Derek Dodson, Georgetown Tani Oluwaseyi, St. John's Samson Sergi, Xavier Yudai Tashiro, Creighton Jacob Montes, Georgetown Tiago Mendonca, Providence Max de Bruijne, DePaul Dylan Nealis, Georgetown Patrick Seagrist, Marquette Joao Serrano, Providence Giannis Nikopolidis, Georgetown Wilmer Cabrera Jr., Butler Luke Haakenson, Creighton Achara, Georgetown Carlton McKenzie, Seton Hall Sean Zawadzki, Georgetown Luka Prpa, Marquette Paulo Lima, Providence Skage Simonsen, St. John's Younes Boudadi, Creighton Brandon Duarte, St. John's Shane Bradley, Villanova Jan Hoffelner, St. John's Brandon Guhl, Butler Jack Haywood, Butler Jared Timmer, Butler Kuba Polat, Creighton Connor Alba, Marquette Josh Coan, Marquette Austin Aviza, Providence Danny Griffin, Providence Brandon Knapp, St. John's Einar Lye, St. John's Derrick Otim, Xavier Matthew Rosenberg, Xavier To earn "consensus" status, a player must win honors based on a point system computed from the four different all-America teams.

[36] Players can play college soccer and still be eligible to sign a homegrown contract.