Bold = winner * = after extra time, ( ) = penalty shootout score Bold = winner * = after extra time, ( ) = penalty shootout score Bold = winner * = after extra time, ( ) = penalty shootout score Bold = winner * = after extra time, ( ) = penalty shootout score Bold = winner * = after extra time, ( ) = penalty shootout score Bold = winner * = after extra time, ( ) = penalty shootout score Bold = winner * = after extra time, ( ) = penalty shootout score Bold = winner* = after extra time, ( ) = penalty shootout score |note= New York Cosmos B had a bye to the Finals Six teams participated in the NPSL Members Cup, formerly known as the NPSL Founders Cup, a competition that ran from August to October 2019 after the conclusion of the regular 2019 NPSL season.
It was intended to lead to a new professional league beginning play in the spring of 2020.
California United Strikers FC officially announced on Twitter that it had withdrawn from both the Founders Cup and subsequent league on March 1, 2019 and were replaced by Napa Valley 1839 FC on March 7, 2019.
They would therefore be dropping out of the tournament "to focus on NISA as (their) preferred path forward.
[13] On August 15, Chattanooga and Detroit City were both announced to be joining NISA in the spring of 2020.