On 24 April 2024, the club booked their place in the 2024 Coppa Italia final with a 4–2 aggregate win over Fiorentina.

[4] Following a 4–1 aggregate win over French side Marseille on 9 May, Atalanta qualified for the UEFA Europa League final for the first time in its history, and went on to win 3–0 against German side Bayer Leverkusen to claim its first trophy since 1963 and first ever European title.

[5][6][7] Note: Flags indicate national team as defined under FIFA eligibility rules; some limited exceptions apply.

Win Draw Loss Fixtures Source: Soccerway Source: Serie A 1 Matchday 21 (vs Internazionale) was postponed to 28 February 2024 due to Inter's participation in the 2023 Supercoppa Italiana.

[43] The draw for the group stage was held on 1 September 2023.