The Falcons were set against Robert Morris, who were playing their first season after a two-year hiatus, and were expected to win the match.
Unfortunately, the Falcons got into power play trouble and allowed RMU to take the lead on the strength of two man-advantage goals.
Garrett Horsager came to the rescue in the third, scoring and then assisting on the game-tying goal to force sending the match into overtime.
With just 10 seconds left, Conner Hasley grabbed the puck behind his cage and tried to made a reverse-pass to Tucker Hodgson.
The Colonial skater who was forechecking predicted the play, intercepted the pass, and wrapped the puck around the front before Hasley could get back into the net.