On 15 May, Sutton United announced their first three pre-season friendlies, against Havant & Waterlooville, Farnborough and Woking.
[47] Win Draw Loss Fixtures Last updated: 27 April 2024 Source: Soccerway
Source: Soccerway On 22 June, the EFL League Two fixtures were released.
[54] On 14 November, Barnsley won their replay 3–0 and were confirmed as the opponents for the U's,[55] However Barnsley were removed from the competition for fielding an ineligible player, therefore Horsham are now the second round visitors.
[60] Win Draw Loss Fixtures In the group stage, Sutton were drawn in alongside Charlton Athletic, Crawley Town and Aston Villa U21.