Forward Madison entered the season as a favorite to contend for the USL League One title, having returned the majority of their roster that reached the playoffs in 2023.

[1] Derek Gebhard became the team's second player to reach 100 competitive appearances for the club in their June 29th USL Cup game at One Knoxville SC.

[6] Forward Madison clinched the Central Group of the 2024 USL Jägermeister Cup with their shootout win vs. Union Omaha on August 29th, moving on to the knockout round of the competition.

[7] They then won their semifinal match at home vs. Charlotte Independence on September 11th to move on to the final of the competition against Northern Colorado Hailstorm FC.

[10] Head coach Matt Glaeser reached his 100th competitive match leading Forward Madison in the club's regular season finale at Northern Colorado Hailstorm FC.