Billy Simon took Crittenden's place just before a second album for A&M Records, which was not released despite producing a chart single, and the group broke up afterward.

Morris, Chapman, and Hilliard reunited with third baritone singer Michael Lusk to release their next album, Getaway Car, on the Fresh label before disbanding a second time.

[1] Before releasing any material of their own, they sang backing vocals on then-labelmate Amie Comeaux's late-1994 debut album Moving Out.

[4] "Cain's Blood", co-written by Michael Johnson and former Poco and Great Plains member Jack Sundrud, was issued as the lead single in early 1995.

The song also had a music video filmed at Hawaiʻi Volcanoes National Park on the island of Hawaii which was put into medium rotation on CMT.

Buddy Cannon, who produced the album with Shell, noted that he did not attempt to change the "vocal blend" present on the group's demo tape, and thus spent more time focusing on the musical arrangements and song selection.

[6] Crittenden quit the group in October 1995 to focus more on a recording studio and publishing company which he owned at the time.

He was replaced by Billy Simon, who made his debut at a concert in Pine Bluff southeast of Little Rock, Arkansas in the same month.

4 Runner also provided background vocals on Craig Morgan's 2003 single "God, Family, and Country",[13] which they also recorded on Getaway Car; also included on the album was their own version of "Love a Little Stronger".

[9][14][15] Crittenden married songwriter Pam "Sunny" Russ and worked as a real estate agent in Missoula, Montana.