In 1995, while on trial at Newcastle United, he broke his ankle and was forced to return to Australia,[2] where he finished school and played junior football for MacArthur Rams and Blacktown City.
He returned to Australia in 2003 to play for St George Saints where in the last match of the season he snapped a medial ligaments in his knee.
He made his league debut on 6 November, as a late substitute for Craig Hignett who had scored both goals as Darlington won 2–1 away to Rushden & Diamonds.
[3] After a game against Adelaide United on 28 December 2006, Webster came to blows with teammate and Glory captain Jamie Harnwell, while the players were still on the pitch.
After leaving Perth Glory, he had a brief spell with Blacktown City Demons before returning to England to work as a personal trainer in Teesside, close to his pregnant girlfriend's home.
[10][11] He moved to Conference North rivals Blyth Spartans at the start of October 2007, but left in April 2008[11] to join Finnish side Myllykosken Pallo -47.