[2] She performed "Because of Who You Are", a song made famous by Sandi Patty, during the talent portion of the Miss Alabama competition.
[7] Entering the state pageant in June 1996 as one of finalists, McCreary's preliminary competition talent for Miss Alabama was singing the gospel hymn "How Great Thou Art" in a contemporary Christian arrangement.
[7][9][10] McCreary won the competition on Saturday, June 15, 1996, when she received her crown from outgoing Miss Alabama titleholder Leigh Sherer.
[12][13] On July 27, 1996, McCreary was honored by the Shoals Chamber of Commerce and presented with a key to the city of Florence, Alabama, by Mayor Eddie Frost.
[1][13][17][18][19] She also won the Quality of Life award and an additional $10,000 scholarship for her community service work related to hospice care.
[23] In December 1990, McCreary was named state champion in original oratory speech during a statewide drama competition.
[25] Between her junior and senior years, McCreary participated in the Musical Theater Project of Tampa, Florida, where she received training and instruction from Ann Reinking, Tommy Tune, Stephanie Zimbalist, and other Broadway theatre professionals.