It was self-released on March 30, 2016, and features performances from Brockhampton members Ameer Vann, Merlyn Wood, Kevin Abstract, Rodney Tenor, Joba, Matt Champion, Bearface, and Dom McLennon.

The bulk of production was handled by group members Romil Hemnani and Joba, with Tenor, Albert Gordon, Bearface, Jabari Manwa, and McLennon also receiving credits, along with guest producer Jeff Kleinman.

[1] All-American Trash was released to positive reception, although retrospectives were critical, often negatively comparing the project to the groups future work.

He also singled out "Infatuation" as a highlight, praising the lush production, "vocals [that] walk the thin line between rapping and singing", and referential lyrics.

Moises Taveras of Paste listed All-American Trash as the groups worst project following the release of Roadrunner: New Light, New Machine (2021).