[3] HipHopDX journalist Luke Gibson cites it as the best-written song from Airtight's Revenge.
[4] Writing for Time Out New York, Mikael Wood describes the music of "All Matter" as "TV on the Radio-style art-funk" and an example of Bilal traversing different styles throughout the album "with the headstrong self-assurance of someone whose commercial aspirations trail his creative ones".
[5] While Bilal's falsetto vocals are sung soulfully and in midtempo, they are arranged against beats played in an aggressive and fast manner.
[4] David Dacks, in Exclaim!, highlights the song as an example of how "Bilal's reedy, Sly [Stone]-meets-Prince voice runs down metaphysical and personal subjects overtop a continuously changing musical landscape".
[6] The lyrics, described by the writer Adrienne Maree Brown as "a meditation on being at peace with every single thing about existence", are sung as follows:[7] We're all the same and all so very different Divine by design, it all intertwines Ain't nothing new but it’s always changing, movin' Still waters soft yet so hard So what is love?… Cool on the outside Hot in the middle but You ain't even gotta try, all you gotta do is realize It’s all matter A speck of dust in this vast universe Just like a raindrop in the sea of consciousness It's all matter… It's everything it ought to be It's everything it needs to be, ok Don't stand in the way You'll only make it hard Just keep it flowing Flow with the ocean and you'll be just where you should be Consequently, Brown likens the song to a "soul sung version" of "A Hopi Elder Speaks", a piece of writing attributed to an unnamed Hopi elder.