It was restored between 1861 and 1862 under the supervision of the architect John West Hugall and the contractor Elliott and Lilley.

The floor was laid with Minton tiles, with those in the sanctuary containing evangelistic symbols.

A reredos was made from the alabaster slab which formed the old altar, and was inlaid with a centre cross of Rouge royal marble and Derbyshire Blue John, and four smaller Maltese crosses.

The font was made of a bowl of Devonshire granite supported on five shafts of St Mary Church Torquay marble, raised on three steps of Mansfield stone.

The restoration work cost £2,000 (equivalent to £235,735 in 2023)[3] and the church reopened on 23 September 1862.