The club has won two "Primera División Venezolana" (First Division of Venezuela's Football) titles in the amateur era.
According to the journalist Eliezer Pérez, in the magazine "El Desafío de la Historia" you can read: "The initiatives gained greater importance when, starting in 1921, Jesuits and Salesians organized the first interclass soccer tournaments in their schools.
In the first, held on October 2, 1921, the America team won 3-2 with goals from Carlos Maal, Aranguren and J.M.
América FCB was mainly made up of students from the catholic Colegio San Francisco de Sales.
In the 1923 championship the América Fútbol Club won its second title, while the runner-up was Centro Atlético.