The school's team competes in the Eastern Intercollegiate Wrestling Association (EIWA).

In 2004–05, Daniel Waters received All-American status by placing 8th at Nationals, becoming the first wrestler in AU history to gain that honor.

In 2006–07, Josh Glenn beat Kurt Backes from Iowa State 6-4 in the NCAA Finals.

In 2007–08, Josh Glenn got 4th place at Nationals, becoming the first 3X All-American in American University Wrestling history.

Kyle Borshoff placed 8th at Nationals, earning his 2nd All-American title in his career.

In 2010–11, the American University Wrestling team not only broke multiple records, but also did the best they ever did at Nationals.

A month after Nationals, Mark Cody took the head coaching job at the University of Oklahoma.

Moore resigned in January 2021 and former Eagles wrestler Jason Grimes was his interim replacement.