The gymnasium was proposed in 1935 by the Works Progress Administration; construction was completed in 1937.

The WPA built many gymnasiums in rural New Mexico during the Great Depression, as these projects provided jobs and a community meeting place to residents.

The gymnasium in Amistad was no different, as it created roughly 50 construction jobs and hosted community dances, gatherings, and sporting events.

Two Zia sun symbols on the front of the building denote its year of completion.

This article about a property in New Mexico on the National Register of Historic Places is a stub.