Critical reception to Anduin focused on his empathy as well as benevolent traits, which is often contrasted to his father's warrior impulses and hardline approach in dealing with the opposing Horde faction.

[4] Once King Varian returned to reclaim his throne, the prince began to focus his efforts on spiritual matters and diplomacy, traveling throughout Azeroth to understand how he might heal lands and souls ravaged by war.

In the Battle for Azeroth expansion, Anduin Wrynn is approached by Wrathion, the son of the Black Dragon Aspect Deathwing, who offers advice and assistance for the conflict against the Old God N’Zoth.

Near the final battle against Zovaal, Anduin manages to break free from the Domination, but is left mentally and emotionally damaged due to his actions while under the Jailer's control.

Still believing he is unworthy of his title, the pair suddenly hear a mysterious voice that beckons them toward the Sword of Sargeras that was plunged into the planet at the end of the Legion expansion.

[9] "Holy Word: Salvation", one of his two "heroic" abilities, is a reference to the World of Warcraft: Battle for Azeroth cinematic trailer, in which Anduin heals his Alliance soldiers in an identical fashion.

[10] Anne Stickney compared and contrasted the actions and traits of both father and son in an article, concluding that while Varian is "a leader of strength and steel against the harsh winter of war", Anduin is "strong in his own right, ready and willing to pick up and mend any heartbreak yet to come".

He noted that while Anduin retained his father's caution in his dealings with the Horde, he comes across as more "open-minded, forgiving, and willing to compromise on things above and beyond him", and said that he had the potential to be a strong, compassionate leader for the humans of Azeroth.

Marshall drew attention to his youth, his close association with the allegedly racist werewolf King of Gilneas, and the fact that he assumes his current position because he is the scion of an absolutist hereditary monarchy as opposed to his merits as leader.