He was a two time league leading scorer with the ASL and was a member of the Canada Soccer Hall of Fame's 2006 Team of Distinction, the 1933 Toronto Scottish.
In 2017, as part of the "Legends Class" he was elected to the Hall of Fame as an individual player.
Stevens remained with the Whalers until 1928–1929 season, but left the team after fifteen games to sign with the New York Giants of the Eastern Professional Soccer League.
The Nationals folded at the end of the season and Stevens returned to Canada where he joined Toronto Scottish.
On June 11, 1933, Toronto Scottish met Stix, Baer and Fuller F.C., the reigning National Challenge Cup champion in a one time North American Soccer Championship.