[1] Casey also wrestled Miss Brenda in a two out of three falls match for the opening of a December 1962 card also featuring Fred Blassie.

[1] With Vivian Vachon as her partner, Casey defeated Donna Christanello and Cora Combs in a 1970 match.

[1] Later that year in December, Casey also won the vacated NWA United States Women's Championship by defeating Toni Rose in a match.

[1] Afterward, she received her paralegal license, as well as a bachelor's degree in criminal justice with a minor in psychology from the University of South Alabama.

[1] Casey's last match occurred in 1990, when she defeated Judy Grable to retain the USA Women's Championship.

[6] After retiring from the ring, Ann Casey wrote an autobiography titled ‘Autobiography of professional woman wrestler, Ann Casey: The Lady, The Life, The Legend.’[4] The book, made available as print-on-demand, comprises more than three volumes and is over 1,000 pages long.

A shorter adaptation of Casey's autobiography appeared in Brooklyn-based sports magazine Victory Journal in December 2014 under the title "The Legend of Panther Girl", with the tagline "She fought to win.