Throughout the late 1990s iconic film director John Waters and comedian Charlie Callas made appearances at the Annoyance.
That location opened with a production of President Bush is a Great Man, directed by Mick Napier.
September 2014, the Annoyance Theater produced Good Morning Gitmo, a one act comedy by Mishu Hilmy and Eric Simon about Guantanamo Bay Detention Center.
The first performance at the Belmont space was Napier's Invisible World on Saturday May 24, 2014 and the company continues to produce original material created by their own ensemble.
The show was created by Tom Troup and Christopher Kervick and starred Tim Heurlin as the mayor of Punxsutawney, PA.[4][5]