The school building was later moved, used as a parsonage by the Zoar Methodist Episcopal Church and then demolished.

David Wilson built the present meetinghouse about 1785, but the building and grounds were not deeded to the Meeting until 1800.

The locally prominent Corbit family and other members began attending the Orthodox meetinghouse in Wilmington, but the Duck Creek Monthly Meeting became Hicksite and retained the property.

The Meeting became a station on the Underground Railroad and Hunn, along with Thomas Garrett was arrested, then severely fined, for helping fugitive slaves.

The building was restored in 1938 by H. Rodney Sharp, opened for worship in 1939, and in 1948 an Appoquinimink congregation was formed.