For the league's first five years, it was held at the arena of the higher seeded team.
However, the 2005 ArenaCup was the first to be played at a neutral site in Bossier City, Louisiana.
The 2006 ArenaCup was played in Coliseo de Puerto Rico in San Juan.
[2] ArenaCup 9 was played at the arena of the higher seeded team, the Spokane Shock.
However, when the AFL announced their televised games would be shown on NBC rather than TNN, the ArenaCup telecast was lost.