While riding off on horseback, Kay (Clay in the Italian version) (Giovanni Pazzafini), shoots and wounds Arizona, but it turns out to be a trick, allowing him to evade the gang.

As the two hang out in the bar, Kay hits on one of the bartender's daughters, a woman named Dolores (Rosalba Neri).

The next morning, Dolores' body is found, and her father, Pete (Pedro in the Italian version), as well her sister, Jane (Corinne Marchand), grieve for her.

Determined to catch her sister's killer, Jane is under the impression Arizona might be him, but thankfully, Pete is able to confirm Kay's identity after Gordo and his men rob the town's bank on that very same day.

From there, Arizona offers to turn Kay in, dead or alive, on the condition he is paid $500, and is allowed to marry Jane.

It's Whiskey, a member of Wacht's gang, that not only steals Gordo's money, but brings the injured Arizona and Kay's corpse back to Blackstone Hill.

Pete and the townsfolk, realizing that Arizona might actually marry Jane, and under increasing suspicion about where Whiskey came from, force the two out of town.

Under the impression that the townsfolk are lying about not knowing their whereabouts, Gordo and his gang rampage the town, and begin killing people.

Paranoid and running out of ammunition, Gordo tries to hide in the gravedigger's shop, where Arizona is able to shoot his limbs, keeping him alive so that the citizens of Blackstone Hill may decide his fate.

She asks him to return one day, to collect his reward, and to stay in Blackstone Hill forever, but once again, Arizona says, "I'll think about that," as he rides off and the credits roll.