Beyeler, a native of Moab, Utah, graduated from Grand County High School, Lamar Community College, and Wichita State University, where he played varsity baseball and majored in communications.

He then spent the 2006 campaign as batting coach for the Mobile BayBears, the Double-A Southern League affiliate of the San Diego Padres, before his return to the Boston organization in 2007.

[4] In his two years as manager of the Pawtucket Red Sox, Beyeler led the team to an International League North Division title in 2011 and its third Governors' Cup championship in 2012.

During that season, Beyeler helped veteran centerfielder Shane Victorino convert to right field, a notoriously difficult position at Boston's home stadium, Fenway Park.

[9][10] After leaving the Red Sox, Beyeler managed the New Orleans Baby Cakes (formerly Zephyrs) of the Pacific Coast League (PCL), Triple-A affiliate of the Miami Marlins, from 2016[11][12] through 2018.