He made a further eight appearances for Blackpool during their 1909–10 campaign, and scored his first League goal for the club in a 3–0 victory at West Bromwich Albion on 16 April.
Wolstenholme's final appearance for the club occurred in the penultimate League game, a 4–1 defeat at Chelsea on 22 April.
During the side's 7–0 win over Chesterfield on 10 September 1921, Wolstenholme became the first player ever to score four times in a Football League Third Division North match.
[1] He ended the season with a tally of 17 goals in 29 league appearances, helping Darlington to a second-place finish in the division behind Stockport County.
He was quickly signed by Nelson manager David Wilson, who had played with Wolstenholme during his time at Oldham Athletic.
He made his debut for Nelson in the 2–6 defeat to Bradford Park Avenue on 26 August 1922 and scored his first goal for the club in the 1–3 loss to Ashington on 7 October 1922.
[6] Wolstenholme netted a hat-trick in the 3–0 victory against his old club Darlington on 23 December 1922 to keep Nelson top of the league after 16 matches of the season.
Wolstenholme was given a coaching role in 1924, but continued to make sporadic appearances for the first-team, scoring two goals in seven matches in the 1924–25 season.