[8] The second season added chef and former football player Eddie Jackson as a team captain alongside Flay and Symon.

Chefs Rodney Scott and Brooke Williamson were added in as the new judges along with television personality Carson Kressley.

[10] The third season consisting of eight episodes brought in chefs Jet Tila and Anne Burrell as new captains alongside Flay.

Discovery announced that it would premiere on July 10, 2023 with a 90-minute special episode and Sunny Anderson would serve as a captain alongside Flay and Burrell.

[14][15] The show returned to Texas for the fifth season, with Michael Voltaggio serving as a captain alongside Flay and Anderson.