"[3] Markos Papadatos of Digital Journal gave the song four stars out of five, calling it "an uplifting and infectious country single."

Papadatos wrote that Corbin's vocals are "pleasant, refreshing and reminiscent of such country superstars as George Strait and Alan Jackson" and added that Corbin "deserves a great deal of praise for staying humble to his musical roots.

"[4] The song also received a favorable review from Taste of Country, which declared it "the sort of timeless tune Corbin began his career with."

It went on to say "the production of the Florida-born singer's most recent cuts isn't as traditional as 'A Little More Country Than That,' but he'll still draw more comparisons to men like George Strait than he will modern Romeos like Luke Bryan, even if he does drop a Dixie cup reference.

Jim Casey of Country Weekly gave the song a "C" and said that it "is as uninspiring as its title suggests.

[10] The song debuted at number 99 on the Canadian Hot 100 chart for the week of June 27, 2015.