Baughman Settlement is an unincorporated community in eastern Hardy County, West Virginia, United States.

In its earliest years, the church was served by local ministers as part of a circuit, including the Rev.

Peter Miller of the Capon North River Parish, who served the church during the Civil War.

The wide eaves of the gable roof are accented with carved brackets, giving the otherwise vernacular structure a Victorian embellishment.

The chancel is raised on a pentagonal platform which is surrounded on three sides by a low communion rail with square balusters.

The walls of the church are covered in plaster with a broad base board and milled crown molding.