Then, in late 2008, Mervyn's filed for Chapter 11 Bankruptcy,[4] and in turn, closed their Eureka store in December of that year.

[4] Following the purchase, plans to remodel the 73,000 square foot Gottschalks space were submitted to the City of Eureka by a contractor for Walmart during the summer of 2011, and opened June 12, 2012.

A localized pizza place entered the mall in January 2015 in the former Sbarro spot, later to be known as Hot Slice Pizzeria, with a clothing store, Salt Tree, going in a vacant lot (but leaving just a few weeks later along with long-time tenant RadioShack).

June 29, 2019 saw the return of Old Navy after leaving the mall in 2009, occupying the spot vacated by Sports Authority three years earlier.

[9] Bed Bath & Beyond was shuttered in 2023 when the company filed for chapter 11 bankruptcy, resulting in the closure of the chain's remaining stores.

Other major stores include TJ Maxx (which opened August 25, 2013), ULTA Beauty, Old Navy,[13] Ross Dress for Less, Staples, and Petco.

Ray's Food Place, a full-service supermarket, was located in a separate building directly south of Kohl's on the same property, but closed at the end of 2013 when parent company C&K Markets declared chapter 11 bankruptcy.