The only time the club won a tie was in 1889–90, when it beat the Edinburgh side Norton Park 6–3.

800 Hearts fans followed their club to Queensferry, and were shocked when Duffy gave the home side the lead "amid deafening cheers".

[6] In 1889–90, the Birds had an unwanted triple, losing to the same side in the Linlithgowshire Cup final in February 1890, this time suffering a 7–0 defeat.

[8] And six weeks after that, the Birds lost 3–0 to Bo'ness in the final of the Consolation Cup at Champfleurie for the East of Scotland Shield.

The club's final reported match was a 3–1 defeat at home to the second Broxburn Shamrock in the King's Cup in November 1894.