The hotel was once owned by the Pineville real estate developer Buddy Tudor, who worked for its historic preservation.

[2] Former owner Robert G. "Bob" Dean, Jr., of Baton Rouge closed the hotel in December 2004 and placed it on the market, at one time asking $12 million.

Hotel Bentley was significant to World War II because of the famous Louisiana Maneuvers which were conducted nearby.

Notable military leaders visiting the area during that time included generals George S. Patton, Jr., Omar Bradley, Joseph Stilwell, and Dwight D. Eisenhower, among others.

In addition to the military figures, the Bentley has hosted such entertainers as John Wayne, Roy Rogers, and Cary Grant.