[4] A string of victories followed, culminating in Taylor and Trent defeating The Inner City Machine Guns to win the 2014 Dynamite Duumvirate Tag Team Title Tournament on January 31.

[5] They subsequently lost a match against The Young Bucks for the PWG World Tag Team Championship at Mystery Vortex II on March 28, 2014.

[6] Best Friends first appeared in Ring of Honor (ROH) on May 14, 2017, joined by Beretta's Roppongi Vice partner Rocky Romero, in a victory over Bullet Club's The Young Bucks and Adam Page.

[7] On October 10, Chuckie T and Beretta won a match against The Addiction to become number one contenders to the ROH World Tag Team Championship, but lost to defending champions The Motor City Machine Guns at Final Battle on December 15.

[8][9] Best Friends made their debut for New Japan Pro-Wrestling (NJPW) on the second day of the 2017 World Tag League on November 19, representing the CHAOS stable.

On the October 30, 2019, episode of Dynamite, Best Friends and Orange Cassidy made their trios debut in a winning effort against Alex Reynolds, John Silver, and Q. T. Marshall.

Best Friends would seek revenge against Jericho and Sammy Guevara (Le Sex Gods) while putting their tag team title #1 contendership on the line on the June 17th edition of Dynamite.

[16] Best Friends would receive their tag team title shot against Kenny Omega and "Hangman" Adam Page at Fyter Fest night 1, which they lost.

Chuck and Trent's feud with Santana and Ortiz culminated on the following episode of Dynamite where they emerged victorious in a Parking Lot Brawl with assistance from Cassidy.

In May, Cassidy challenged for the AEW World Championship in a three-way match against the champion Kenny Omega and PAC at Double or Nothing, but was unsuccessful.

On the December 17 episode of Rampage, CHAOS (Chuck, Trent, Orange, and Rocky) defeated Bobby Fish and the Superkliq (Adam Cole and the Young Bucks) in an 8-man tag match.

After months of the factions trading wins and losses, Cassidy faced Adam Cole in a lights out match at Beach Break.

At the same time, Bryan Danielson, while floating the idea of a stable with Jon Moxley, made overtures towards Yuta by naming him as a potential understudy.

[21] On the March 30 and April 8 episodes of Dynamite and Rampage respectively, Yuta would lose to the newly christened Blackpool Combat Club in increasingly competitive matches, with the latter match with Moxley finally resulting in Regal offering a bloodied Yuta a handshake, which he accepted, before painting "BCC" on his chest with his blood, signifying his departure from Best Friends and CHAOS and initiation into the Blackpool Combat Club.

With help from Danhausen who stopped PAC from using the hammer again, Cassidy defeated his longtime rival and won his first championship in AEW, celebrating with Best Friends after the match.

In the middle of this, Chuck and Trent participated in a four-way match for the ROH World Tag Team Championship at Death Before Dishonor, but were unsuccessful.

On the August 3 episode of Rampage, Jon Moxley and Claudio Castagnoli defeated Chuck and Trent in a Parking Lot Fight, brutalizing Orange Cassidy with the help of former Best Friends member Wheeler Yuta, and destroyed Sue's van in the process.

After the match, Moxley, Claudio, and Yuta attacked Cassidy, who was saved by Chuck, Trent, the Lucha Brothers, and Eddie Kingston.